Unlearning Marx: Why the Soviet Failure was a Triumph for Marx

Unlearning Marx: Why the Soviet Failure was a Triumph for Marx

  • Downloads:4001
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-04-22 13:50:59
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Steve Paxton
  • ISBN:178904541X
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

The theories of Karl Marx and the practical existence of the Soviet Union are inseparable in the public imagination, but for all the wrong reasons。 This book provides detailed analyses of both Marx’s theory of history and the course of Russian and Soviet development and delivers a new and insightful approach to the relationship between the two。

Most analyses of the Soviet Union, from any perspective, focus on trying to explain the failure to establish socialism, giving too much weight to the political pronouncements of the regime。 But, for Marx, this approach to historical explanation is back-to-front, it's the political tail wagging the economic dog。 When we move our focus from the stated aims of building socialism, and look at what actually happened in Russia from emancipation in the 1860s, through the Soviet era to the 1990s, we can clearly see the patterns which Marx identified as the essential features of the transition from feudalism to capitalism in England from the sixteenth century to the nineteenth。 As such, the Soviet experiment forms an important part of Russia’s transition from feudalism to capitalism and provides an excellent example of the underlying forces at play in the course of historical development。

Unlearning Marx will surprise Marx’s admirers and his detractors alike, and not only shed new light on Marxism's relationship with the Soviet Union, but on his ongoing relationship with our world。

Download

Reviews

Ed Rose

This book takes a controversial approach to understanding the Soviet Union through Marx's theory of history。 It's clear and assumes no prior knowledge of either, but still gets right into the details。 Recommended。 This book takes a controversial approach to understanding the Soviet Union through Marx's theory of history。 It's clear and assumes no prior knowledge of either, but still gets right into the details。 Recommended。 。。。more

Michael Constance

A clear and original thesis, a new take on the Soviet Union, plus quite a bit on Marx as a historian which is less well known than his political and economic work。 Quite concise but well documented with loads of notes - I read the ebook which makes the notes easy to check as you go through, there are often extra little bits of information, not just references for figures and quotes etc。

Stella Leeman

If you're tired of listening to Jordan Peterson fans repeat a load of nonsense about Marx, but didn't really have the tools to set them right, this book will help you out。。。The person who recommended it to me commented that it's a quick read because you get the whole argument in the first third - the rest is just technical discussion and historical evidence - but actually almost all of that is really readable - most of the theory sections are interesting and clearly written (there was one sectio If you're tired of listening to Jordan Peterson fans repeat a load of nonsense about Marx, but didn't really have the tools to set them right, this book will help you out。。。The person who recommended it to me commented that it's a quick read because you get the whole argument in the first third - the rest is just technical discussion and historical evidence - but actually almost all of that is really readable - most of the theory sections are interesting and clearly written (there was one section I struggled with) and the historical chapters are interesting because they focus on providing the evidence to back up the theory, rather than just narrating a succession of leaders and policies。 (Wrote the same review by mistake on the Kindle edition, but should have been here - haven't got a kindle。) 。。。more